Our Dressings & Sauces


Whether you like a little or a lot, sauces and dressing add flavor and depth to pizza, salad, appetizers – is there anything that sauces and dressing don’t make better?

Pizza Sauce

Heavy tomato paste and ground tomatoes (sourced from Stanislaus™ - the top brand in tomatoes, and a family-owned American company ) create the robust base for our pizza sauce. We then add oil, a little sugar, and our secret blend of spices. The sauce cooks on your pizza, giving it a richer, fresher flavor.

Margarita Pizza Sauce

We again start with high quality Stanislaus™ roma tomatoes (a combination of diced and strips). We add olive oil, basil, and fresh garlic to build a sauce that is more chunky than liquid.

House Dressing

Our long-time customers will tell you that there is nothing better than our house dressing. Fresh onions, fresh garlic, and grated romano cheese are blended with our secret spice blend to create the flavor that keeps folks coming back again and again. This dressing isn’t just for salads either – try it on breadsticks, scarpa, Stromboli, your pizza crust – or even straight! (Contrary to rumors, there is nothing illegal in our dressing to make you become addicted.)

Other In-House Sauces

We take the same care in making our other sauces, including our marinara, alfredo, and pesto. We also make our own buffalo sauce – a combination of sweet (honey and brown sugar), savory (butter), and spicy (hot sauce and cayenne pepper).

Top Brands

Although we would like to, we can’t make every dressing and sauce from scratch. For those items that we don’t make, we source the top brands: Hidden Valley Ranch™, Sweet Baby Ray’s™, Ken's™, Kraft™, and Newman’s Own™.

Store Information

Nico's Pizza

255 W Cougar Blvd, Provo, Utah 84604, United States

(801) 356-7900


12 PM (noon) - 8 PM Monday - Saturday

Closed Sunday

(We hope to resume normal hours soon)

Drop us a line!