Literally the BEST
Best of State
Our Boston-style, East-coast pizza was judged best in Utah for 2018!
Best of Utah Valley
Customers chose us for three categories in 2018 - Pizza Restaurant, Italian Restaurant, and Customer Service! Thank you!
PIZZA BY THE SLICE!
In a hurry? You can now buy our pizza "by the slice." Our generous slice is almost as big as a personal pizza! Also available as a combo. Come grab a slice today!
COKE FREESTYLE!
With over 120 different drink options, and an app to create more, you can't beat the Coca-Cola Freestyle machine!
FREE LITTLE LIBRARY!
Just like on the streets of Boston, we have our own "Free Little Library." Come in and take a book or share a book. Always free.
What would you like to do now?
Learn More
Read all about our approach and ingredients to understand what makes our food so delicious
Browse Menu
Check out all we have to offer. Your mouth will be watering by the time you are through
Place an Order
Place an order online to pick-up in the store (either to carry out, or just to have ready for you to enjoy)
What is Nicolitalia?
Years of success
Nicolitalia has been the place for pizza in Provo for over a decade. Find out why!
"Boston-style"
Each region has its own style of pizza. Come experience what makes "east-coast" pizza amazing!
Everything you love and more!
We have new ownership, a new nickname, and some new options, but also all your old favorites.